CodexBloom - Programming Q&A Platform

MySQL 5.7: Inconsistent Results with GROUP BY and HAVING Clauses in Complex Queries

๐Ÿ‘€ Views: 1542 ๐Ÿ’ฌ Answers: 1 ๐Ÿ“… Created: 2025-06-05
mysql group-by having sql SQL

This might be a silly question, but I'm stuck on something that should probably be simple. I've been banging my head against this for hours. I've searched everywhere and can't find a clear answer... I'm working with an scenario with MySQL 5.7 where my query returns inconsistent results when using `GROUP BY` along with `HAVING`. The query is intended to aggregate data from a sales table, filtering out any entries based on total sales per product. Here's the query I'm using: ```sql SELECT product_id, SUM(sales_amount) AS total_sales FROM sales GROUP BY product_id HAVING total_sales > 1000; ``` The goal is to retrieve only those products that have total sales exceeding 1000. However, when I run this query, I occasionally receive products that have total sales below this threshold. I've even tried running the same query multiple times in a row and noticed that sometimes the results change. To troubleshoot, I checked for any potential data anomalies, such as duplicate entries, but everything appears to be clean. I also tried using `DISTINCT` in the `SELECT` clause, but that didn't help resolve the scenario. Hereโ€™s a sample of my sales data: ```sql INSERT INTO sales (product_id, sales_amount) VALUES (1, 500), (1, 600), (2, 200), (2, 300); ``` When I run the initial query after these inserts, it returns both product 1 and product 2, which doesnโ€™t make sense since their total sales should be 1100 and 500 respectively. I've considered potential issues with transaction isolation levels, but I'm running the default settings. Is there something I could be missing here with how MySQL handles the aggregation and filtering? Any insights would be greatly appreciated! This is part of a larger application I'm building. Thanks in advance! I'm working on a application that needs to handle this. How would you solve this? I've been using Sql for about a year now.