CodexBloom - Programming Q&A Platform

C# - Unexpected Behavior with LINQ When Grouping by Complex Types in .NET 6

πŸ‘€ Views: 0 πŸ’¬ Answers: 1 πŸ“… Created: 2025-06-16
LINQ C# Grouping Equality

I've looked through the documentation and I'm still confused about I'm integrating two systems and I'm relatively new to this, so bear with me... Quick question that's been bugging me - I'm encountering unexpected behavior when using LINQ to group a list of custom objects by a complex property in .NET 6... The data structure I'm working with is as follows: ```csharp public class Product { public int Id { get; set; } public string Name { get; set; } public Category ProductCategory { get; set; } } public class Category { public int CategoryId { get; set; } public string CategoryName { get; set; } } ``` I have a list of `Product` objects, and I am trying to group them by `ProductCategory`. Here's the LINQ query I've written: ```csharp var groupedProducts = products.GroupBy(p => p.ProductCategory); ``` However, I find that when I attempt to iterate through the `groupedProducts`, I'm getting an inconsistent number of groups. Specifically, if two products have the same `CategoryId` but different `CategoryName`, they are being treated as different categories. This is not what I expected since I believed LINQ would use the default equality comparison for the `Category` objects. To troubleshoot, I tried overriding `Equals` and `GetHashCode` in the `Category` class: ```csharp public override bool Equals(object obj) { if (obj is Category category) { return this.CategoryId == category.CategoryId; } return false; } public override int GetHashCode() { return CategoryId.GetHashCode(); } ``` I also confirmed that the `ProductCategory` is not null. After making these changes, I still observed the same grouping issue. Here’s the output I get when iterating through `groupedProducts`: ```csharp foreach (var group in groupedProducts) { Console.WriteLine($"Category ID: {group.Key.CategoryId}, Products Count: {group.Count()}"); } ``` This outputs distinct counts for categories that I expected to be grouped together. Am I missing something in how LINQ handles grouping by complex types in .NET 6? Any insights or best practices would be greatly appreciated. For context: I'm using C# on Linux. Is there a better approach? For context: I'm using C# on macOS. How would you solve this? I'm open to any suggestions. I'm working with C# in a Docker container on macOS. Thanks for your help in advance!